Proposition 127: Prohibit Bobcat, Lynx, and Mountain Lion Hunting in Colorado
Proposition 127: Prohibit Bobcat, Lynx, and Mountain Lion Hunting
A YES vote on Proposition 127 will prohibit bobcat, lynx, and mountain lion hunting and trapping in Colorado. It will allow on a permit basis the killing of these animals under certain circumstances such as livestock depredation.
As a lifetime hunter and fisherman and most importantly, wildlife conservationist, I understand both sides of this issue. Hunters and trappers want to protect the opportunity to hunt and trap. Wildlife advocates, enthusiasts, and conservationists are interested in viewing wildlife as well as the welfare of each wildlife species.
After spending over 30,000 hours in the field studying and filming mountain lions and bobcats I’ve learned that these animals, as keystone species, have an outsized positive impact on the ecosystems they inhabit. They deserve wildlife management that supports their welfare and works to maximize the overall health of their populations. Mountain lions and bobcats do not benefit from being hunted or trapped. Only hunters and trappers benefit. From a wildlife conservation standpoint, that’s unacceptable. Solid science and research supports the fact that mountain lions, bobcats, and lynx self-regulate their populations. There is no scientific evidence that hunting and trapping are necessary to control their populations.
Wildlife in Colorado is managed to benefit the visitors and residents of Colorado
The Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission Policy states that Colorado wildlife are managed for the use, benefit, and enjoyment of Colorado visitors and residents.
Every wildlife species has a set of biological and ecological factors they are dependent upon for a healthy population. Every wildlife management plan should support these factors as the primary goal of the plan. The current goal for mountain lion and bobcat management is simply maintaining a population that can be hunted and trapped. But if the act of hunting and trapping mountain lions and bobcats does not improve the welfare of these species, then the activity must be called into question. As of October 2024, Colorado Parks and Wildlife doesn’t have a bobcat management plan, has no idea how many bobcats are in the state, and yet allows each hunter and trapper to kill as many bobcats as they want. From a wildlife management perspective, this is completely unacceptable.
One of the most important biological factors that determines the health of these wild feline populations is kitten survival. Each year, mountain lion kittens are orphaned because a female mountain lion was killed by a hunter. Colorado Parks and Wildlife does not count these kittens that starve to death because they aren’t of breeding age. Respected mountain lion biologists and researchers will tell you that if you are going to hunt mountain lions, no more than 22% of the harvest should be female lions of breeding age. In Colorado, 46% of the mountain lions killed by hunters each year are female lions.
Violating the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation
The North American Model of Wildlife Conservation (NAM) is often cited as the gold standard of wildlife conservation by hunters, trappers, fishermen, and outfitters. NAM was a response to the market hunting that was decimating wildlife in North America.
A key tenet of this model is:
- elimination of markets for wildlife
This was put in place to prevent the selling of any part of an animal for profit. The trapping and hunting of bobcats and selling their pelts is a clear violation of this tenet.
Fair Chase Rules Violated by Mountain Lion and Bobcat Hunting and Trapping
Fair chase is a term used by hunters to describe an ethical approach to hunting big game animals. It refers to the pursuit and taking of any free-ranging wild game animal in a manner that does not give the hunter an improper or unfair advantage over the game animals.
The use of any of the following methods in the killing of a game animal is considered Unfair Chase. The bold items indicate how Fair Chase is violated in Colorado.
- Artificial light
- Electronic devices for attracting game (bobcat)
- Use of aircraft or other motorized vehicles (mountain lion)
- Use of drugs to immobilize animals
- Use of dogs to pursue or take game (mountain lion, bobcat)
- Use of bait to attract game (bobcat)
Note pages 4 and 5 from the CPW regulations: https://cpw.widen.net/s/kmpdszcx6j/ch03
The price of a bobcat pelt in China or Russia determines how many bobcats are killed each year. During the 2023-2024 season, a total of 955 bobcats were killed by hunters and trappers, and during that same time, only 10 bobcats were killed because of livestock conflicts.
Bobcats, along with mountain lions and lynx, do not need to be hunted or trapped to “control” their populations. This has been proven in national parks and other areas where hunting and trapping are not allowed. Neither of these species spiraled out of control due to lack of hunting and trapping.
A YES vote on Proposition 127 would maintain the flexibility of CPW to kill mountain lions and bobcats when they are preying on livestock and at the same time support the positive impact these animals have on the ecosystems they inhabit.
This author’s attitude is a perfect example of what’s wrong with humans. How in hell is it OK to kill, torture, or maim any being except to eat? And because humans can’t hunt naturally, i.e. with their bare hands, the ways in which we hunt must be severely restricted in order to prevent immoral and undue suffering of our prey.
Furthermore, hunting should be strictly limited to natural prey species, such as rabbit, deer, and elk. If no other animal normally eats a species, that species should not be hunted, period. This means that the subject animals here should be off limits to hunting. F ranchers and their damn destructive cattle & domestic sheep, predators like these should NEVER be killed under any circumstances, period!!!
I wonder with mountain lions if a light hunting season that allows some take, as well as dogs, would be a net positive with reducing human/cougar conflict? There are lots of credible reports of habituated cats in the suburban/rural interface, including some high-profile attacks lately. It seems like a light hunting season may keep some of these frisky adolescent males on their toes with humans, therefore giving the species overall better public relations. I’m all for protecting bobcat and lynx. Wasn’t lynx already not huntable? What’s changing?